Writer's Blog (megancrewe) wrote,
Writer's Blog

Discussion: Naming the competition

Okay, so this isn’t about books, but it is about words and how things are written, which is good enough, right? :)

In the last couple months there’s been an ad campaign war of sorts between two major Canadian companies. Both are claiming to offer a service for less than the competitor, and both are clearly targeting the other. The difference is in how.

When I first saw this ad, and the TV ads that go with it, I thought it was kind of cute. The reference to the competitor is quite sly (the competitor’s logo is blue).

A couple weeks later, these ads started showing up, and my jaw dropped. Calling out the competition by name! Really classy. :P

Companies calling out their competition is nothing new–I grew up with Duracell vs. Energizer commercials. But to me, how it’s done has a pretty big effect on how I feel about the ad. And ads that go out of their way to name their competition… just seems like poor taste to me. I’m actually less likely to buy a product or service if I see a company turning to those sort of tactics.

(Actually, I could see this coming up with book promotion, too… To me there’s a pretty big difference between saying something like, “No sparkly vampires here!” and something like, “My book is way better than Twilight!”)

What about the rest of you? Does it bother you when a company (or whatever) targets another in their promotional efforts? If it’s subtle? Overt? Or do you figure anything goes in advertising?

  • Share/Save/Bookmark

Originally published at Megan Crewe - another world, not quite ours. You can comment here or there.

Tags: discussion

  • A book shout-out: A Corner of White

    Today’s shout-out goes to Jaclyn Moriarty’s A Corner of White: I’d enjoyed the previous books by Moriarty that I’d…

  • A book shout-out: Cuckoo Song

    It always makes me sad when I read a book that is really lovely, and notice that not many people seem to be talking about it. So I’m going to…

  • New book from a departed friend

    Many of you, I hope, are familiar with L.K. Madigan’s work: her debut novel, Flash Burnout, won the William C. Morris Award. Sadly Lisa was…

  • Post a new comment


    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded